У Return To Monkey Island первые оценки довольно неплохие

Return To Monkey Island early review scores

Eurogamer 'Recommended'

GamesHub 5/5

AusGamers 9.5

IGN 9

The Independant 9

GamesRadar+ 4.5/5

Press Start 8.5

The Guardian 4/5

Gamepur 8

OC 92 (8 critics)

https://opencritic.com/game/13681/return-to-monkey-island

MC 93 (4 critics)

https://www.metacritic.com/game/pc/return-to-monkey-island